Main Menu
  • Forum
  • Guidelines/Rules
  • Florida Fishing Guides
  • Contact/Advertising
  • Texas Fishing Forum
  • Louisiana Fishing Forum
  • Georgia Fishing Forum
  • Advertisement
  • Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission
  • Coastal Conservation Association Florida
  • FFF on Facebook
  • International Game Fish Association
  • Florida Guides Association
  • The Florida Keys & Key West
  • Visit Florida
  • Advertisement
    Caymas Boats
    Newest Members
    JWat, DEERSTRANGLER, wetjetcaptain, tnfisher, Moses
    2734 Registered Users
    Top Posters(All Time)
    BeachBum 1,200
    Bo Patro 1,124
    FFF Staff 727
    Seapro 364
    Murrydog 265
    BobGlen 261
    Forum Statistics
    Most Online1,278
    Feb 28th, 2020
    Print Thread
    Can Someone Tell me How to catch these Mayan Cichlids.......... #8199 01/20/13 03:12 PM
    Joined: Jan 2013
    Posts: 1
    Cut-Throat Offline OP
    Green Horn
    OP Offline
    Green Horn
    Joined: Jan 2013
    Posts: 1
    I am renting a house in Naples Florida, which has a small 1/4 acre pond behind the house. Everyday, Anahingus Birds come into the pond and within 5-10 minutes they come up with a Nice Sized Fish. I have identified the fish as a Mayan Cichlid. Since the birds are so successful at fishing, I am guessing that there are a load of them in the pond.

    I have tried various methods to catch them, but have been unable to thus far. I am a Fly Fisherman and was hoping to get these fish on my 5 weight fly rod. I tried everything that I could think of matching what the Cichlids eat. small fish, shrimp, insects etc. to no avail. Fast retrieve, slow retrieve, surface, on the bottom etc.

    So, I tried some bait to see if I could catch them. First I tried some sweet corn on a small hook. The bobber sat there for a half hour until I caught a turtle. Then some bits of fresh shrimp, again the bobber sat there again for about a half hour until I caught 2 turtles.

    While fishing I have never seen any Mayans following my fly or swimming in the water. Or any surface activity. I have seen a couple of small Largemouth Bass and flipped my fly to him and he promptly ate and was caught.

    Can someone help me unlock this mystery? Am I right in assuming that there must be a load of Mayans here if the birds are so successful? What bait would be the best to catch these Mayans? They would be an ideal Fly Rod fish, if I could 'Crack the Code'.

    Re: Can Someone Tell me How to catch these Mayan Cichlids.......... [Re: Cut-Throat] #8373 02/22/13 09:52 PM
    Joined: Nov 2012
    Posts: 265
    Murrydog Offline
    Joined: Nov 2012
    Posts: 265

    Molon Labe

    Previous Thread
    Next Thread

    © 2007-2021 OUTDOOR SITES NETWORK all rights reserved USA and Worldwide
    Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3